Larvicidal activity, molluscicide and toxicity of the essential oil of Citrus limon peels against, respectively, Aedes aegypti, Biomphalaria glabrata and Artemia salina

85 Eclética Química Journal, vol. 44, n. 4, 2019, 85-95 ISSN: 1678-4618 DOI: 10.26850/1678-4618eqj.v44.4.2019.p85-95 Larvicidal activity, molluscicide and toxicity of the essential oil of Citrus limon peels against, respectively, Aedes aegypti, Biomphalaria glabrata and Artemia salina Paulo Roberto Barros Gomes1+ , Marlucy Bezerra Oliveira2, Dionney Andrade de Sousa2 , Jeremias Caetano da Silva1, Romer Pessôa Fernandes2, Hilton Costa Louzeiro3 , Rayone Wesly Santos de Oliveira2 , Maria do Livramento de Paula4 , Victor Elias Mouchrek Filho2 , Maria Alves Fontenele5


Introduction
The essential oils extracted from citrus plants arouse in man the interest in identifying his constituents and the possible applications to society. Among the identified compounds, the main ones are limonene, β-myrene, α-pinene, p-cymene, β-pinene, terpinolene [1][2][3] , and its applications are in medicine, food, cosmetics, detergents, aromatherapy, inhibition of pathogens and control of insects. Among the major chemical constituents found in citrus, we highlight limonene. In the nomenclature adopted by IUPAC (International Union of Pure and Applied Chemistry), it has the name of 4-isoprenyl-1-methyl-cyclohexene and constitutes more than 300 plant species. In addition, it has two enantiomers which are S -(-)limonene R -(+) -limonene, in which R -(+) - limonene is the major component of oils from lemon peel (Citrus limon) and orange peel and of the essential oil of Carum carvi, being responsible for the prevention of dehydration and inhibition of microbial growth 4 .
In the literature, it was observed that the limonene was found to have larvicidal and molluscicidal activity against Dysmicoccus brevipes 5 and Lymnaea acuminata 6 . Based on this information, we asked: did the essential oil extracted from the bark of C. limon have larvicidal activity against the third stage larvae of Aedes aegypti and molluscicide against the snail Biomphalaria glabrata, both disease vectors, respectively, dengue and schistosomiasis? Therefore, the fight against the vectors of dengue and schistosomiasis occur through, respectively, larvicides and synthetic molluscicides. Among the larvicides and molluscicides recommended by the World Health Organization (WHO), are, respectively, the temephos and niclosamide 7 . However, the use of these larvicides and molluscicides provokes resistance of larvae and snails, low selectivity, environmental contamination and high cost [8][9][10] . Thus, it is recommended studies of extracts of plants 7 and larvicides.
There are two essential points in the manual of the World Health Organization (WHO) 11 on the efficacy of a plant's molluscicidal activity, although the same does not exist for larvicidal activity. One is about the activity of the extracts. These are considered to be active when the 24 h shellfish mortality is equal to or greater than 90% at the concentration of 20 ppm for extracts and 100 ppm for the raw vegetable. Another is on toxicity and field studies. Even if the natural molluscicides are biodegradable, within the values required by the WHO, they may present risks 7 .
In this context, in our toxicity study, we chose to carry it out with Artemia salina for two reasons. One, low cost, easy manipulation and a good indication of non-target organisms 12,13 . Another study, due to the good results of plants with the molluscicidal activity that used A. salina in the toxicities test 14,15 . Hence, in view of the above, we chemically characterized the essential oil extracted from the bark of C. limon and tested the larvicidal activity against larvae in the third stage of A. aegypti, molluscicidal activity against the snail B. glabrata and toxic activity against larvae A. salina.

Obtaining essential oil
We collected the fruits, branches, and leaves of C. limon in the district of Sá Viana (January and June 2010), in the peripheral region of São Luís/MA, directly from the lemon tree, which is free of agricultural pesticides. In the Seabra Attic Herbarium (SLS) of the Federal University of Maranhão (UFMA), we identified this species from the observation and comparison with the part already identified in the herbarium under registration number 100379 (family Rutaceae, genus Citrus). After this step, we removed the fruit peels with a stylet.
To extract the essential oil, we used a glass Clevenger extractor coupled to a 1000 mL round bottom flask and to an electric blanket as a heat source. To each essential oil extraction routine, we weigh and grind in an electric sample mill 30 g. After this step, we mixed the sample with distilled water in the proportion 1:10 and placed in a round bottom flask, coupled to the extractor system. Then we switched on the electric blanket and set the temperature to 100 °C. After 5 h the distillation was stopped, and the essential oil was collected. The oil is dried by means of percolation in anhydrous sodium sulfate. We performed these operations in triplicates and stored the samples in ampoules of amber glass under refrigeration (temperature of 15 °C) to avoid possible losses of volatile constituents. So, we determined the density of the essential oil extracted from the use of a 1.0 mL pycnometer, previously dried, tared and calibrated.

Chemical analysis
For the chemical analysis, we used the gas chromatographic technique coupled to the electron impact mass spectrometer and ion trap analyzer (GC/MS). The equipment used was of the Varian 2100 brand, using helium as drag gas with flow in the column of 1mL min -1 ; injector temperature 270 °C, split 1:50; (15 m × 0,25 mm) with stationary phase VF-1ms (100% methylsiloxane 0.25 μm) and oven temperature programming of 60 to 200 °C with a heating rate of 8 °C min -1 and 200-290 °C with heating rate of 15 °C min -1 . In the mass spectrometer the manifold, ion trap, and transfer line temperatures were 50,190  20 μL in 1.5 mL of hexane were injected. We have identified the components of the oil from the comparison of these with the data obtained from authentic substances in reference libraries 16 .

Collection and cultivation of Aedes aegypti larvae
In this way, we collected eggs at the Federal University of Maranhão, Bacanga Campus in São Luís Maranhão, through traps called ovitraps. These consist of black polyethylene pails with a capacity of 500 mL each, where we put water and insert two eucatex vanes into the mosquito. We inspect the traps weekly for replacement of the reeds and egg collection. After this step, we placed A. aegypti eggs to hatch at a temperature of 31 °C in a 200 mL polyethylene vessel with mineral water. We fed the larvae with cat food until they reached the third stage, when the experiments were done.

Test of larvicidal activity
We prepared a 1,000 mg•L -1 stock solution from the 50 mg weighing of the oil into a solution of 49.75 mL of distilled water and 0.25 mL of Tween-80. From this, we prepared five solutions at the concentrations 5, 10, 30, 50 and 70 mg•L -1 . For each concentration, we used ten larvae and 30 mL of each solution in the cited concentrations. We performed all the tests in triplicate and as negative control we used a solution formed by 49.75 mL of water to 0.25 mL of Tween-80, and as a positive control, a solution of Temephos ([4-(4dimethoxyphosphinothioyloxyphenyl) sulfanylphenoxy]-dimethoxy-sulfanylidene-λ 5phosphane), which is equivalent to the concentration used by the National Health Foundation (Funasa) for the larvicidal control of the vector, in addition to Novaluron (N-[[3-chloro-4-[1,1,2-trifluoro-2-(trifluoromethoxy)ethoxy]phenyl]carbamoyl]-2,6difluorobenzamide) at 0.02 mg•L -1 , a dose adopted by the Brazilian Ministry of Health, which indicates by the World Health Organization in the range of 0.01 to 0.05 mg•L -1 .

Malacological investigation
From this, we collected the samples of snails in the natural breeding sites of the neighborhood Sá Viana, the periphery of São Luís, Maranhão. The catch was carried out during rainy periods, with the use of PPEs (personal protective equipment), such as glove, boot seven leagues, and metal tongs. The collection technique consists of scraping the submerged areas with the shell and the collected snails were placed in a glass container with a lid, with water from the breeding site itself 17 . The search of the same ones was realized in several points of each breeding place, in order to obtain a good sampling. After collection, these were labeled by the breeder and taken to the laboratory for identification and analysis. From the technique of dissection of the genital apparatus 18 , we identified the snails as belonging to the family Planorbidae, genus Biomphalaria, species B. glabrata.

Snails positivity test
For instance, we placed five snails in clear glass vials (30 mL capacity) with 25 mL of dechlorinated water, that is 5 mL per snails, brought to light exposure (100 W lamps), at a distance of 30 cm, during 1 h, to stimulate the release of cercariae 19 . After exposure, the glasses were taken for analysis by means of a stereoscopic magnifying glass 8x. Those that were parasitized (positive) were labeled and separated for future individual analysis in order to verify which was contaminated and those that did not show signs of infection by the trematode in the period of 30 days were selected for the molluscicidal activity test. The period of analysis of the snails was every 7 days, for one month (30 days) to confirm the absence of larval stages.
So, after the positivity test, we placed the snails in polystyrene containers with dechlorinated water and fed with hydroponic lettuce for future test of molluscicidal activity.

Molluscicidal activity test
The molluscicidal activity was performed according to a manual described by the World Health Organization. To do this, we placed 10 adult snails, negative for Schistosoma mansoni in each beaker containing 500 mL of a solution obtained from the dilution of each oil with distilled water and 0.15 mL of Tween 80 (surfactant) at the concentrations of 100, 75, 50, 25, and 10 mg L -1 , obtaining at the end a proportion of 50 mL of solution for each snail and feeding them with hydroponic lettuce ad libittum 20 . They were exposed to the solution for 24 h at room temperature. After this period, the snails were removed from the solution and the snails were washed twice with dechlorinated water, placed in each beaker containing 500 mL of dechlorinated water, fed with hydroponic lettuce and observed every 12 h (method recommended 24 h) for four days to assess mortality. To confirm the activity, we observe the mollusks. If the cephalopods mass is retracted into the shell, release the hemolymph, or swell and extend the cephalopod out of the shell, it is considered dead 21 .

Toxicity test with Artemia salina
So that, the Artemia salina Leach cysts were transferred to an aquarium containing the synthetic saline solution (60 g of sea salt / liter of distilled water) and oxygen saturation, obtained with the aid of an air pump. The aquarium was divided into two interconnected compartments, the cysts remaining in one of the compartments, leaving the second compartment under artificial illumination of a 100 W lamp. After 24 h, the cysts hatched, the larvae migrated to the lighted compartment because they had phototropism positive. These were transferred to an aquarium containing synthetic saline and kept in incubation for another 24 h under the same lighting and oxygenation conditions. The methodology used was described by Meyer at al. 22 but with modifications.
For the evaluation of the lethality of A. salina Leach, 20 mg of the oil was added to 0.02 mg of Tween 80, the volume was filled to 2 mL with artificial saline. This dilution was done to obtain a 10 mg mL -1 stock solution and a concentration of 0.1% Tween 80. Samples of 5, 50, 250 and 500 μL of this stock solution were transferred to vials with 5 mL of final solution, obtaining concentrations of 10, 100, 500 and 1000 mg·L -1 , respectively. Ten larvae in the nauplii phase were transferred to each flask. White (saline) was made with 20 μL and the negative control (saline and 0.1% Tween 80) was made with 20 μL. After 24 h of incubation, the live larvae were counted, considering those microcrustaceans that did not move during observation and with slight agitation of the flask. Thus, we adopted the criterion established by Amarante et al. 23 , which consider LC50 samples less than 100 mg L -1 , highly toxic; with LC50 between 100 and 500 mg·L -1 , moderately toxic; and LC50 greater than 500 mg·L -1 nontoxic.

Statistical analysis
The statistical test used was Anova of single factor and Tukey's posterior test to identify significant differences. For the calculation of the lethal concentration (LC50), we used the Probit method 24 . For mortality results, we expressed these results with mean ± standard deviation. For all statistical tests, we considered the significance of p ≤ 0.05.

Evaluation of the chemical characteristics of the essential oils obtained by gas chromatography coupled to mass spectroscopy (GC/MS)
Before identifying and quantifying the components present in the oil, we performed the kinetic test for extraction in the time interval of 0.5 to 5 h to verify the best performance. From this test, we verified that from 3 to 5 h, the oil yield remained constant, obtaining a volume of 0.35 mL. We calculated the extraction yield from the mass we used, which was 30 g of the material, volume obtained after extraction, of the density measurement, which was 0.823 g•mL -1 and the formula expressed by the Brazilian Pharmacopoeia 52 . From this, the result obtained was, respectively in the ratio mass / volume and mass / mass, of 1.17% and 0.96%.
From this study, we identify and quantify the components present in the oil. The result of the GC-MS analysis showed 23 peaks, which indicated the presence of 23 compounds (Fig. 1). In comparing the mass spectra of the constituents with the NIST 8 library, we identified the 15 compounds (Table  1). Based on the results, we observed that the major component is Limonene (58.81%) and the minority is the α-Mulene (0.11%) ( Table 1)

Larvicidal activity, molluscicide and toxicity
We tested the larvicidal activity for concentrations of 5, 10, 30, 50 and 70 mg L -1 , molluscicide for 10, 25, 50, 75 and 100 mg L -1 and toxicity for 10, 100, 500 and 1000 mg L -1 . In all tests, we observed an increase in the percentage of mortality with the increase in concentration and absence of interference of the biological activity in the control test. Thus, they were higher in  (Table 3).

Discussion
From this study, we showed that the essential oil extracted from the bark of C. limon has larvicidal activity, molluscicide and toxicity. This may be a viable alternative to synthetic larvicides and molluscicides, since they would act against target organisms due to their toxicity against other organisms. We found that the percentage (m/v) of the oil yield was 1.17% and that the main components are limonene (major component) and α-Mulene (minor component).
The yield that we obtained in a time of extraction of 5 h was 1.17%, in which this value remained constant in the interval of 3 to 5 h. The study of the yield allows to evaluate the time necessary to conserve the best characteristics of the oil. According to Mouchrek Filho 25 , quoted by Gomes et al. 26 , a time of rapid extraction leads to a product with the predominance of more volatile constituents, but without the best characteristics. Otherwise, slow distillation overloads the product with undesirable flavors 54 . Generally, the best yields are obtained from the time of 3 h [26][27][28][29][30] .
From the chromatographic method coupled to the mass spectrometer, we identified and quantified limonene as the major component of the essential oil extracted from C. limon peels. Thus, we confirm what has already been described in the literature regarding this component for citrus substances. However, we observe that the quantity of this differs from other works, where they are generally above [31][32][33] and others below 50%. The redirection of plant metabolic pathways to lead to the biosynthesis of different compounds [34][35][36] and abiotic factors are responsible for caused changes in the composition of C. limon essential oil.
In the study of larvicidal activity, the essential oil was active against the third stage larvae of A. aegypti in the concentration of 70 mg•L -1 with 100% mortality of the larvae tested. Although this result gives us a dimension of biological activity, a statistical calculation of the lethal concentration (LC50) from the method of Finney 24 gave us an estimate of inferring this result for a population, considering a statistical distribution of the normal type. The result of LC50 was 15.48 mg•L -1 . From this result, we compare the criteria adopted by Cheng et al. (2003), since up to the moment of this research there is no criterion established the World Health Organization 37 to consider active larvicidal activity or inactive. According to the Cheng et al. 38 the larvicidal activity of the essential oil is active when the LC50 <100 mg•L -1 ; inactive when LC50> 100 mg•L -1 is highly active when LC50 <50 mg•L -1 . Thus, from this classification the essential oil we extract from the bark of C. limon is considered highly active.
The larvicidal activity of the essential oils are influenced by several factors. A study by Fernandez et al. (2014) 39 showed that larvicidal activity is higher in spring, summer and autumn, and lower in winter, confirming the influence of seasonality; for Leyva et al. 40 synergistic action among metabolites (even in small proportions), the collection period and the extraction method are responsible for this; while other studies attribute this action to terpenes, alcohols, and aldehydes [41][42][43] .
For these reasons, the results of our study confirm the larvicidal and insecticidal activity of limonene of C. limon essential oil against the genus Aedes. The study carried out by Campolo et al. 44 showed the activity of this oil against Aedes albopictus larvae with a lethal concentration (LC50) of 145.27 mg L -1 after 24h exposure. However, the study of larvae, pulps and adults of Aedes albopictus 45 confirmed the activity of the oil with a lethal concentration (LC50) of 35.99 and 34.89 mg•L -1 for the enantiometric forms of limonene, respectively, R -(+) -limonene and S -(-)limonene. Finally, the study Amer and Mehlhorn 46 confirmed that activity against third-stage larvae of A. aegypti was higher at 24 h exposure time when compared to shorter times. Thus, the difference that these studies have with the results of our study is in the low value of the LC50 that we obtain. To explain this difference, we attribute seasonality, collection and extraction factors and synergism.
In relation to molluscicidal activity, the essential oil was active with LC50 13.48 mg•L -1 . In this case, to affirm this, we compare the result obtained from the LC50 with the criteria used by the WHO 11 . According to this criterion, the extract obtained from the plant is active when it causes mortality of 90% of the aquatic mollusks at the 24 h exposure time, under constant temperature and concentration up to 100 mg•L -1 47 . Thus, we proved that the result we obtain from the LC50 of our study is within the limits established by the WHO.
Besides the molluscicidal activity which we show in this work, we observed in the literature that the limonene obtained from the Carum cravi seed powder showed activity against the snail Lymnaea acuminata 6  the lethal concentration, LC50, for a population of these snails did not meet the criteria established by WHO 11 , whose value was 130.61 mg•L -1 in the time of 24 h. In addition, this study left craving for the percentage absence of limonene contained in the extracts, in which it left doubts about its effectiveness.
In the literature there are other plants that have molluscicidal activity against B. glabrata, however, the effectiveness is in the lowest value of the lethal concentration (LC50). The study of thirteen Solanum species revealed that the extracts of the species S. asperum, S. diamantinese, S. paludosum, S. sisymbriifolium and S. stipulaceum present activity with lethal concentration (LC50) varying from 20 to 50 mg L -1 48 ; Moringa oleifera Lam seed extracts were active in the lethal concentration, LC50, 419 mg L -1 49 ; extracts from the stems of Melloa quadrivalvis and Tabebuia aurea and whole plants of Adenocalymma comosum, Arrabidaea parviflora, Cuspidaria argentea, and Clytostoma binatum have activity with LC50 concentration varying from 5.2 to 37.5 mg L -1 , being the most active Cuspidaria argentea, LC50 5.2 mg L -1 50 ; the essential oil of Pimenta dioica is active with LC50 18.62 mg L -1 , however the toxicity study showed that it is highly toxic to other organisms 53 . Though, the Ocotea bracteosa essential oil has activity with concentration, LC50 4.6 mg L -1 51 . Although O. bracteosa essential oil has good results in lethal concentration values, the absence of a study of toxic activity in this study raises doubts about its effectiveness in a real system.
Hence, faced with this impasse, when performing the study of toxicity, we evaluated the possibility of the action of oil against non-target organisms. In our study, we used A. salina because of the following characteristics: formation of dormant cysts, low cost, easy manipulation in the laboratory and indication of interference with nontarget organisms 12,13 . Based on the toxicity parameters of Amarante et al. 23 , the essential oil, with LC50 = 743.35 mg L -1 , is non-toxic (LC50> 500 mg L -1 ). In addition to our study, we found in the literature extracts from six plants of the family Bignoniaceae that have moderate to low toxicity with LC50 values varying from 485.5 to 815.4 mg L -1 50 .

Conclusions
In this manner, according to the results obtained in this study, we can conclude that the essential oil extracted from the shells of C. limon has larvicidal activity and molluscicide, respectively, third stage larvae of A. aegypti and snails B. glabrata, and non-toxic front A. salina. In addition, we identified and quantified the majority and minority components, which were, respectively, limonene and α-Mulene.  [7] Cantanhede, S. P. D., Marques, A. M., Silva-Souza, N., Valverde, A. L., Atividade moluscicida de plantas: